Match reaction: Newcastle Falcons 15-21 Edinburgh Rugby

photo (4)

Friday 29 August 2014 – 7.45pm

Mansfield Park, Hawick



I quite enjoyed the drive up to Hawick last night, the M6 was a bit crazy but the A7 really is a lovely and peaceful road. Driving back was a bit hairier than I remember last year – for some reason I felt quite sleepy so tried to get forty winks at a layby not far from Langholm, but couldn’t, so fuelled up with some chocolate and Coke to get through the last seventy miles.


I felt fortunate to be able to lock the car. A dark, remote winding road between England and Scotland was probably rich pickings for bandits in past centuries.


Aye, we can go back to Hawick next year, nice little ground with a neat little bar, and a nice scholarly-looking picture of Scott MacLeod with his Scotland cap on the wall.


On the pitch, the Falcons put together a more sustained performance than against Rotherham, with plenty of aggression and Juan Pablo Socino showing a lot of creativity at fly-half, suggesting that he might be the one to lead the promised new expansive game from the number ten shirt.


Simon Hammersley again showed solidity in defence and pace and guile in attack and will surely make his Premiership debut at Welford Road next Saturday. He might be joined by some Tuilagis in the backline, both Alex and Andy looking in decent shape to get at least part of the game next week. The centres are a bit problematic if Socino wears ten, but Jamie Helleur did his chances of a start no harm with a combative second half last night.


In the forwards, Calum Green again carried well and made some big tackles. I quite like this guy. Hopefully whatever problem led to Dom Barrow being taken off in the first half will not keep him out of the opening league game, and was just a precaution. In the back row, I’d be tempted to go for the balance of speed and power by picking Mark Wilson, Andy Saull and Ally Hogg. Despite Will Welch being in the lineup, Hogg led from the front last night, a controller at the base of the scrum and making good metres in the loose.


As well as the back row, one area of the forwards where Dean Richards might have a selection problem is at hooker, where George McGuigan shows no signs of stopping his development into a top player, performing excellently last night, but where we also have current Scottish international Scott Lawson and new signing Rob Hawkins available, not to mention Matt Thompson. I’d be tempted to throw McGuigan in from the start next week – his performance in the loose last night reminded me a bit of Schalk Brits and that’s quite a compliment.


I suppose the key problem again last night was that we didn’t take our opportunities when we were on top for much of the second half, and allowed Edinburgh to creep further ahead with penalties. Discipline is going to have to improve in the Premiership, and we also need to keep scoring tries if we are not going to be able to rely on Phil Godman’s boot – despite another lively showing, he missed a relatively simple conversion last night.


Overall, there were probably more positives than negatives in Hawick. It’s just a shame we couldn’t secure what would have been a big morale-boosting win, but keep plugging away and playing an attacking game, and the wins will come.



(Follow The South Stand Choir on Twitter: @SouthStandChoir)


One response to “Match reaction: Newcastle Falcons 15-21 Edinburgh Rugby

  1. Always good to read about a game from the oppositions point of view. I thought we, Edinburgh, played fairly well, good so see Big Viss back scoring. It was also quite pleasing to see a very young side hold their own in the last 20mins.
    Good luck for the season ahead:-)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s