Match reaction: Newcastle Falcons 16-22 Gloucester Rugby


Sunday 29 September 2013 – 3.00pm

Kingston Park, Newcastle

Aviva Premiership #4


Today’s defeat yielded a bonus point for the Falcons, but other results mean we drop to eleventh in the table, four points ahead of next week’s opponents Worcester.


Dean Richards will surely have targeted today’s home clash with Gloucester as a must-win, making the visit to Sixways on Saturday doubly important now. A win would take the gap over the Warriors to up to nine points, but defeat makes the relegation battle a little hotter.


Obviously we got off to the best possible start this afternoon with Tom Catterick scoring our first try of the season, and a 10-0 lead was just reward for the Falcons whose forwards had their Gloucester counterparts on toast for most of the game.


The away backs always looked dangerous though, particularly the lightning wingers James Simpson-Daniel and Jonny May, and it is probably no surprise that we were outscored on tries. The forwards were given responsibility at the death for getting a potentially-winning try but were unable to.


The referee will take some stick for ending the game with a decision of held-up, but fans closer than me agreed with the decision and you have to question why several Falcons players got excited and piled in when being patient and calm had given us several attacking phases. Keep going and eventually the try will come – there’s no rush.


Another bad decision that will haunt the Falcons was to give Tom Catterick a shot at goal with ten minutes left rather than go for the corner, at three points down. It was a heck of a long way out and we were starting to get back into the game after two dodgy middle quarters, so why not go for the corner? Mind, if he’d scored and we had gone on to get a draw or even a win, nobody would have complained.


Catterick had a solid, if not particularly spectacular, game I thought. Adam Powell was given man of the match but I thought Alex Tait had another blinder at full-back, and James Fitzpatrick did little wrong. Mike Blair is showing signs of the speed and cleverness we have so long lacked at scrum-half.


Dominic Barrow and Ally Hogg had huge games up front and Oliver Tomaszczyk has definitely become more mobile over the summer. Franck Montanella is a top scrummager and Matt Thompson really put his opposite number under pressure in the tight.


Ultimately, our inability to get out of our 22 with some of the best backs around bearing down, and a lack of execution in the final quarter, let us down I believe – lets not forget that Freddie Burns missed a few kicks at goal so Gloucester could have scored more.


Overall, it wasn’t a disastrous result, and we have one more point from our first four games than we gained from the equivalent fixtures in 2011/12. We are improving with every game, however the key is to turn performances into victories, starting at Sixways on Saturday.


As I contemplate a two-hour drive home, and whether or not I have enough fuel to get to the (relatively) cheap garage near Carlisle I saw on the way over yesterday, I’m not hugely downheartened.


Could really do with a beer though!



(Follow The South Stand Choir on Twitter: @SouthStandChoir)


2 responses to “Match reaction: Newcastle Falcons 16-22 Gloucester Rugby

  1. Cant disagree with you, but would raise the following if i may…
    We seemed to leave the wing unguarded and pull into the middle. This clearly made space and they targeted Noah pn the wing as it became almost an empty channel. This given the less than stellar defensive tackling left us open and we were punished.
    Going into the game, my guess was us by 3, and it doesn’t feel like bonus point earned, more like points dropped.

    Your thoughts ?

    • Definitely, Noah was isolated for their third try as we got pulled left and didn’t realise they were building an overlap. Noah (and Catterick) too didn’t have a great day defensively I thought, and but for Alex Tait drifting there could have been more tries.

      I had this down as a win as we normally do beat Gloucester at home and they don’t tend to travel that well. Being in an early lead and then pounding them in the last 10, I agree it does feel like points dropped. Over the whole 80 minutes I think it’s our best performance of the season so far, but a half hour of silliness lost the win.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s