Match preview: Bristol Rugby v Newcastle Falcons

Sunday 2 September 2012 – 3.00pm

Memorial Stadium, Bristol

RFU Championship #1


15 years ago we had only spent one league season out of the second tier, while Bristol had never experienced it. Now, we visit the South West in our first game in the lower division since then. Having spent three years in the Championship Bristol will be as keen as us to get back to the Premiership and this game already looks like an indicator of whose ambitions, if either, will be fulfilled.


Yes, the season finally begins and we can see the Richards Revolution in full swing!


The fixture list has not been kind to either of the promotion favourites by sending us to Bristol on the opening day of the season but if we can get the win, or maybe even repeat our last visit to the Memorial Stadium, then it will set a marker down after what may be on paper the hardest game of the year.


The last time we were in Bristol, if you don’t know was ‘Judgement Day’ on Friday 13th February 2009. We were seven points above the hosts and had the opportunity to all-but send them down with a win, while if Bristol were victorious they would have a chance of overtaking us.


In the end we didn’t need to worry, as tries by Geoff Parling, Ed Williamson, Brent Wilson and Andy Perry grabbed five points in a 3-35 win. It was Glory Night I, and only our second victory at the Mem in the league, the other being a huge 8-50 on the way to the 1997/98 title.


Falcons in BS10:

08/02/1975 Cup R2                       W13-3

23/02/1980 Cup R2                       W14-3

04/12/1993 Division 1                   L0-26

27/12/1997 Premiership 1           W50-8

23/04/2000 Premiership 1           L11-30

17/12/2000 Premiership               L14-27

24/02/2002 Premiership               L17-33

10/11/2002 Premiership               L10-38

09/04/2006 Premiership               L7-23

18/02/2007 Premiership               L21-22

14/10/2007 Premiership               L16-23

13/02/2009 Premiership               W35-3



Bristol had a tricky pre-season schedule and lost at Agen, Narbonne and Munster, though they were not disgraced by any of the scores, before finishing off by thumping Clifton at Cribbs Causeway last Thursday night.


Liam Middleton has assembled a decent squad ahead of his side’s fourth attempt to get back to the Premiership, with 32-year-old, 43-cap Scottish prop Bruce Douglas joining from Worcester and potentially pairing up with Jason Hobson, who has one England cap as a replacement in New Zealand in 2008. Argentinian international Gaston Cortes joined this week but is still awaiting a visa.


Half-backs Adrian Jarvis and James Grindal, much-maligned at KP but popular in two spells at Leicester, have masses of top level experience, as does former Bedford and Harlequins forward Roy Winters, now starting his eighth season with Bris.


Former Saracens winger Mike Tagicakibau played in last year’s World Cup for Fiji. Grindal is joined in the squad by several other former Falcons, namely Glen Townson, Luke Eves and Redford Pennycook, the latter pair in their second spells in the South West after returning to the Memorial Stadium during last season.


More quirkily, former Exeter centre Bryan Rennie also arrived in the summer and is sponsored by his own fan club!



For his first competitive match in charge, Dean Richards gives debuts to Andrew Higgins, Alex Crockett and Oliver Tomaszczyk, while Tane Tu’ipulotu is a starter on his return, as is, more surprisingly, Sean Tomes. Rory Lawson and Waisea Luveniyali are on the bench.


Falcons: 15 Luke Fielden, 14 Andrew Higgins, 13 Alex Crockett, 12 Tane Tu’ipulotu, 11 Ryan Shortland, 10 Jimmy Gopperth, 9 Chris Pilgrim, 1 Jonny Golding, 2 Rob Vickers, 3 Oliver Tomaszczyk, 4 Sean Tomes, 5 James Hudson, 6 Ally Hogg, 7 Will Welch (c), 8 Taiasina Tu’ifua.

Replacements: 16 Matt Thompson, 17 James Hall, 18 Scott MacLeod, 19 Richard Mayhew, 20 Rory Lawson, 21 James Fitzpatrick, 22 Waisea Luveniyali.


Bristol: 15 Jon Goodridge, 14 Mike Tagicakibau, 13 Jack Gadd, 12 Luke Eves, 11 Ryan Edwards, 10 Tristan Roberts, 9 James Grindal, 1 Kyle Traynor, 2 Ross Johnston, 3 Wayne Thompson, 4 Mariano Sambucetti, 5 Glen Townson, 6 Ian Grieve (c) 7 Redford Pennycook, 8 Marco Mama.

Replacements: 16 Rhys Lawrence, 17 Bruce Douglas, 18 Ben Glyn, 19 James Merriman, 20 Ruki Tipuna, 21 Matthew Jones, 22 David McIlwaine.



After a nice summer recovering from the relegation battle of last season (though I think I’m still recovering from Gloucester!) it’s time to get going again.


Howay the Falcons!



(Follow The South Stand Choir on Twitter: @SouthStandChoir)


Match reaction: Ulster Rugby 24-20 Newcastle Falcons

Although I’ve only seen one of our Falcons’ pre-season games, that v Edinburgh, by all accounts we look to be in pretty good shape heading into the Championship season.

Last night’s 24-20 defeat to Ulster isn’t a bad result in a friendly (obviously in a competitive game it would be) considering they are the second-best team in Europe and we are, well, second division.

Dean Richards took charge last night for the first time and lets remember he has been away from the coal face for three years.

With Ulster 24-8 up in the closing stages, the Falcons kept plugging away and got two late tries, something that a year ago we might have been more surprised.

Especially since Taiasina Tu’ifua spent more time in the sin bin. Hopefully he’ll be in there a bit less this season.

So we can probably deduce a few things about team selection from the friendlies. Oliver Tomaszczyk looks likely to start in the number three shirt at Bristol next Sunday, alongside Rob Vickers in the front row.

Jimmy Gopperth, Rory Lawson and captain Will Welch are likely to be automatic selections most weeks, probably joined by returning midfielder Tane Tu’ipulotu and Lawson’s compatriot Ally Hogg.

Carlo del Fava, Scott MacLeod and James Hudson might rotate in the second row.

We seem set to see little of Greg Goosen and Michael Mayhew, judging by pre-season, although there will inevitably be injuries.

So a week tomorrow we head to Bristol to start the league season with infinitely more optimism than when we took on Bath a year ago.

So much has happened since then that it seems an age ago, but the key is that the club has rediscovered its pride and self-respect, have probably our strongest coaching team ever, and the fans are back on-side.

The fact we are in the Championship will hopefully prove only a blip. But one we can enjoy with some great new away days.

Viva la revolucion!

(Follow The South Stand Choir on Twitter: @SouthStandChoir)

Match reaction: Newcastle Falcons 21-3 Edinburgh Rugby


Friday 17 August 2012 – 8.00pm

Kingston Park, Newcastle


The Falcons’ win over Edinburgh last night ended the home pre-season in fine style and suggests we may well have something to work with this year.

It may have only been a friendly but we outplayed the Heineken Cup semi-finalists and barely gave then a sniff of the tryline.

It wasn’t Dean Richards’ first game in charge but from his lofty perch in the West Stand the new gaffer will have been pleased with most of what he saw, along with the majority of the crowd.

It was the first time I and no doubt some others had seen a few of the new signings and I was particularly impressed with Scott MacLeod. Already popular on the terraces, the Scot impressed in the lineout and with some enthusiastic work around the field.

I didn’t notice Oliver Tomaszczyk too much but not every scrum can drive several metres forward and since it was generally solid he most likely did OK.

Tulip looks aggressive on his return and he made several good breaks through the Edinburgh defence, taking men with him and making several metres on most occasions.

His centre partner Alex Crockett seems to be a big bloke, and his running style at kick-off was more that of a prop. Didn’t see too much from him last night so we’ll have too see what happens.

I didn’t notice Carlo del Fava or Chris York much either.

Wesley Luvey (even I’m not taking on his name just yet) seems a lively player despite being built like Tai, and looks creative but maybe a target for attackers as was said after last week’s games.

Obviously our big-name signing this summer is Rory Lawson and on his short second-half debut the Scot moved the ball quickly and used the box kick effectively, both things we have struggled with in recent years.

Frankly, as you might expect from an experienced international, Lawson already looks on a different level to some of the scrum-halves we’ve become used to.

Overall, it was a strong showing against a club that is in a different league to us, metaphorically as well as legally and geographically. Bar their early penalty and a short spell near the end of the first half, Edinburgh rarely has serious ball in our half.

More important battles lie ahead but it seems from the pre-season so far that things are looking up, and it’s not often in recent years we’ve been able to say that in August.

Two weeks from tomorrow the league season finally starts – bring on Bristol!

(Follow The South Stand Choir on Twitter: @SouthStandChoir)

Falcons in Division Two 1996/97


(Second photo from


It is amazing to think that once upon a time, back when Sir John Hall took over Newcastle Gosforth as was, our club had only spent one season in the top division, and it weren’t pretty. Most of our league history had been spent in the second tier.

1996/97 was the last time our team began a season in the second level. Newly-branded Newcastle Falcons, Rob Andrew took his star-studded squad on a pre-season tour of South Africa before the serious business began in September in the final year of the Courage League.

Waterloo were the first opponents in Division Two, and faced the following team at KP: Tim Stimpson, Ross Wilkinson, Andy Blyth, Graham Childs, Tony Underwood, Rob Andrew, Gary Armstrong, Nick Popplewell, Ross Nesdale, George Graham, Richard Metcalfe, Peter Walton, Richard Arnold, Dean Ryan.

Wilkinson, Popplewell and Andrew scored tries and Andrew’s boot secured a 30-13 win in front of over 1,400 spectators, to get the season underway successfully.

Nottingham were the first team to host the Falcons, who gave a debut to Garath Archer in his second spell at the club. The Midlands side presented less problems than Waterloo, as Armstrong scored four tries in a 29-74 victory, however the four tries conceded were a worry. The defence, by now including John Bentley on the wing, fared better against Blackheath at home the following week, when Bentley scored twice and 41-cap All Black John Gallagher’s side were put to the sword 61-0.

The first televised match of the season for the Falcons took place at Richmond, a team promoted in the summer but already with ambitions similar to Newcastle having signed England stars Brian Moore and Ben Clarke, the much-respected Welsh international Quinnell brothers and their compatriot Allan Bateman. Rob Andrew and former Gosforth full-back Simon Mason’s boots were on target all afternoon, and after Tony Underwood gave his side a first half lead, the Falcons needed a late score from Gary Armstrong to rescue a 20-20 draw in front of nearly 7,000 at the Athletic Ground in South London.

From probably the hardest match of the season, Newcastle returned to Kingston Park to meet Rugby Lions, and ran up a Courage National League record win of 156-5, with hat-tricks from Ross Nesdale, George Graham, Dean Ryan and Gary Armstrong, while John Bentley, Matt Tetlow, Tony Underwood and Nick Popplewell scored twice. The other scores came from Tim Stimpson, Andy Blyth, Doddie Weir and replacement Steve Bates (remember him?), Andrew converting 18 of the 24 tries.

In front of England management team member John Elliott, Blyth, Stimpson and Bentley all impressed at Wakefield on October 12th when the Falcons inexplicably lost the penalty count 26-6 yet won 17-47 against the last team to win in the league at Kingston Park. Bentley scored a hat-trick a week later in a 9-75 win against Moseley, when the home side never threatened a Falcons side who led 9-35 at half time before scoring the last six of their eleven tries after the break.

The second game of the season against another promotion favourite, and Kingston Park’s first live TV game of 1996/97, was against Bedford who had signed Rugby League legend Martin Offiah as well as former England prop Jeff Probyn. However, two early tries (penalty try and Matt Tetlow) saw the Falcons begin to pull away from the blues and cement their potential to walk away with promotion to Division One.

There was a reality check however at Coventry, where despite five penalties and a drop-goal from Rob Andrew, the home side triumphed 19-18 at Butts Park in front of 8,000 passionate supporters with an injury-time Jez Harris drop-goal. The Falcons were forced to play the second half of their first defeat of the season without John Bentley, who was red-carded for punching just before the interval.

Normal service of sorts was resumed at London Scottish when the Geordies returned to the automatic promotion places with a 28-12 victory after three tries from Tim Stimpson and three Rob Andrew penalties.

After a break of a month from domestic rugby, and a week after the Falcons defeating their cup opponents in an away friendly, December 23rd saw the first competitive North-East derby of the professional era when West Hartlepool visited Kingston Park in the Pilkington Cup fifth round. The contest between the high-flying Falcons and their Durham opponents, who were odds-on for relegation from Division One, was in reality not a contest with John Bentley and Gary Armstrong putting the hosts 18-3 up after 17 minutes, and in the end both Armstrong and Underwood completed a 51-10 win over West, as Newcastle recorded a record crowd of 4,665 who saw the team’s second rugby league convert, Scotland’s Alan Tait, make a debut at centre.

The early January weather meant postponements in the league which would create a fixture pileup later in the season, and it wasn’t until January 25th that the Falcons played their first match of 1997, returning to London Scottish in the sixth round of the Cup. Without knowing they were playing for a plum tie at home to Bath or Leicester, Newcastle scored six tries to repeat their victory at the Athletic Ground in November, this time 15-39, including a 40 metre effort from Nick Popplewell early in the second half which he added to at the final whistle.

The latest recruit to the star-studded Falcons squad made his bow in the return to Division 2 duty in February, Western Samoan captain and flanker Pat Lam, and the new man wasted no time in scoring a first half try. Although the score was never going to reach the 156-5 of the reverse fixture, an impressive 8-70 win was registered in preparation for the club’s biggest match so far in the professional era – the Pilkington Cup quarter-final against Leicester.

Rumours had circulated that the tie would be moved to Gateshead International Stadium or even Newcastle United’s St. James’ Park in anticipation of a huge crowd, but in the end 5,700 crammed into a sold-out Kingston Park to witness the clash against a Leicester team fielding the England front row of Graham Rowntree, Richard Cockerill and Darren Garforth, fellow internationals Craig Joiner, Austin Healey and Neil Back, future Lions captain Martin Johnson, and South African World Cup-winning fly-half Joel Stransky.

Despite an early penalty from Rob Andrew, it was Stransky’s boot which decided the match with six kicks, before Pat Lam scored a consolation minutes before full time. Andrew claimed afterwards that with better preparation (three relatively simple games since the middle of November) his side could have beaten the European Cup runners-up, however Newcastle had shown they could take on and compete with the best teams in England, and would certainly not be pushovers in the top division.

Out of the Cup, the Falcons now had to concentrate solely on winning promotion, and went into the first of four successive home matches in March, against Wakefield, with £1m new signing Va’aiga Tuigamala in the team, the man Doddie Weir called “Quite simply the best rugby player in the world”. A bumper 3,000 crowd witnessed the match in which John Bentley furthered his case to be included in the British Lions squad to tour South Africa with a hat-trick as the Yorkshiremen were put to the sword 57-10.

A week later Nottingham visited Kingston Park just a day after several Falcons played for their national sides in the 5 Nations Championship, including Rob Andrew who had been a replacement for England. Continuing injuries to Nick Popplewell and George Graham also threatened the Geordies, but in the end made little difference and a second half hat-trick by replacement Steve Bates, adding to tries from Garath Archer (2), Martin Shaw, Dean Ryan and Gary Armstrong ensured a 53-17 victory.

A further 14 scores saw off Moseley, with 66 points scored in the second half and Va’aiga Tuigamala getting on the scoresheet for the first time with a hat-trick as the Midland side were crushed 88-19. However, this was just a warm-up for the eagerly-awaited top of the table meeting with Richmond at home on March 29th, with the Falcons needing a win to have any chance of topping the second division at the end of the season.

With their first choice XV on the pitch, and backed by a 5,000+ crowd, the Falcons raced into a 24-10 lead by half time thanks to tries from Dean Ryan, Nick Popplewell and Garath Archer, and man of the match Doddie Weir made the game all but safe after the break before Rob Andrew kicked his second and third penalties, and Ben Clarke’s late score was little more than a consolation for Richmond. Ahead of further big games with Bedford and Coventry, Newcastle were most definitely on course for Division 1.

Just a week later though, the promotion drive was slightly threatened at Goldington Road, Bedford, as the Blues won 34-28 in a controversial match which saw Popplewell sent off for a punch on Scott Murray. Going into half time the Falcons were 10-3 down, however a Darren Edwards try in injury time gave the hosts a good cushion, and although Alan Tait, Pat Lam and George Graham crossed in the second half, it wasn’t enough to prevent their side’s second defeat of the season in front of the Sky cameras.

The first defeat, at Coventry, could be avenged at Kingston Park and Newcastle made an immediate signal of intent with Ross Nesdale scoring after less than a minute, and John Bentley followed soon after. The Geordies trounced their promotion rivals by a massive 49-17, with Nesdale scoring again and Tim Stimpson, Graham Childs, Rob Andrew, Alan Tait and Va’aiga Tuigamala all grabbing tries. The road to the top division looked relatively straightforward now, with only five games to go and the Falcons expected to win each one comfortably.

Five wins would indeed seal promotion, and looked on the cards from the start as two away games followed, firstly at Blackheath on Wednesday April 16th when twelve tries put the Londoners to the sword 10-72 in what Rob Andrew called the team’s best away performance of the season. This was followed up three days later by a 21-45 victory in Rotherham, meaning only three points were required from three games to hold off Coventry and secure automatic promotion.

What had been scheduled to be the final match of the season was London Scottish at home. Any thoughts of a slip-up were put to one side and in front of 2,507 fans Tim Stimpson shared the kicking duties with Rob Andrew, eight of the 10 tries being converted. Va’aiga Tuigamala and Gary Armstrong both crossed twice as the Exiles were destroyed 71-20.

There was no let-up in the final away game at Waterloo either, 66 points being put on the board with the 24 conceded being a mere statistic.

The scene was set for a final day promotion party at KP and over 3,400 people packed KP to see a 61-13 victory that included five scores from Pat Lam and a fitting pair by player of the year Gary Armstrong.

Although Richmond pipped the Falcons to the Division Two title by a point, 40 to 39, Newcastle had scored 1255 points to the Londoners’ 986 and conceded 64 fewer points, in a dominant league season.
At the end of the day, promotion was all that mattered. The title the club really wanted would come a year later.

(Follow The South Stand Choir on Twitter: @SouthStandChoir)

Under-the-clock Chronicles: Part 1

Since I haven’t posted anything for a while, here is the first of a possibly one-part series, with a few thoughts ahead of the new season.

So for the first time in 16 years we face a season outside the top flight. But, as with the team containing Rob Andrew, Gary Armstrong and Dean Ryan back in 1996, we begin as favourites for promotion.

Frankly, even considering the play-offs, with the money, squad and management the Falcons have, if we don’t go up we will have no excuses.

If rumours of Euan Murray departing, even for a loan spell, turn out to be true, that will not change.

All we have to do is keep our heads, show respect for the opposition and play to our potential. If we do that then I have no doubt that in a year’s time we will be looking forward to returning to Bath, Gloucester and Northampton.

Complacency may be one of our most difficult foes but having our two hardest games (on paper) in the first month – Bristol and Pirates away – should help guard against that.

We will probably struggle in a number of matches this season, we could even lose a few because that is how sport goes. But I for one intend to have a damn good time in the Championship.

We have our first visits to Penzance, Doncaster and Jersey and a first trip to Plymouth since the amateur era.

We will also renew acquaintances with Rotherham, Bedford, Nottingham, Moseley and London Scottish, and regular top flight opponents Leeds and Bristol.

A lot of those sound far more exciting than another afternoon at a half-empty Madejski Stadium.

Just for a season though please!

(Follow The South Stand Choir on Twitter: @SouthStandChoir)